I mean, I’ve been around a while, so it can’t be “us Fedi dwellers”, since… you know, I’m pat of that, so I would be part of the “we”, so surely you meant something else, right?
Because man, would it be some weird self-defeating irony to imply that in a thread where one is defending a mostly vibes-based argument that the culture in “our” place is actually uniquely diverse and free-form due to the way the thing is designed. That’d be a remarkable self-own.
So I’m sure it’s not what you meant.
Look, deal with it however you need, I don’t particularly mind, but it’s one of many self-serving, semi-deliberate misaprehensions people around here like to lean on to dismiss the current limitations of Fedi’s setup, and that habit does bum me out. Because, you know, being part of this community, despite your implications, I would like for it to be more popular than it is. Not fully mainstream, perhaps, because I do like the weird, cozy mid-90s forum feel of the thing, but… yeah, a bit.
And definitely I would have liked to see Masto put up more of a fight instead of being steamrolled by Elon. That was a legitimate bummer.
Did I ever claim to be trying to do that? I mean, it’s starting to get convoluted, but my initial point was that people attribute effects to decentralization it doesn’t have by itself, so the differences between the more consolidated Bluesky ecosystem and the less consolidated Masto ecosystem in particular aren’t as meaningful as the graph in the OP suggests.
You were the one who popped up to claim that decentralization prevents monocultures. I just disagreed with that statement and pointed out that… yeah, that’s one of the magic effects people claim that don’t seem to really happen.
Whether that’s a problem or how big of one is entirely up for debate. All I’m saying is it’s not much of a real advantage, as far as I can tell. I’m both here and in BS, so I clearly don’t find either that effect or the lack of that effect to be a dealbreaker, if it exists at all. I’m claiming it doesn’t exist in the first place.
My educated guess is that what would meaningfully change how this conversation is playing out is me unequivocally siding with the home team and bashing the away team. The fact that I’m not necessarily bashing either (or at times I’m bashing both) is perceived as hostility or siding with the away team, because people have squishy brains and that’s how the Internet works and all social media was a mistake.
Hah. That is a shockingly… optimistic? take in a world where even Twitter didn’t crash and burn. I would ask how resilient that level of delusion is to observable reality, but refer to my earlier comments about social media and squishy brains.
deleted by creator
“Our”?
What “our” is that? Who’s “we”?
I mean, I’ve been around a while, so it can’t be “us Fedi dwellers”, since… you know, I’m pat of that, so I would be part of the “we”, so surely you meant something else, right?
Because man, would it be some weird self-defeating irony to imply that in a thread where one is defending a mostly vibes-based argument that the culture in “our” place is actually uniquely diverse and free-form due to the way the thing is designed. That’d be a remarkable self-own.
So I’m sure it’s not what you meant.
Look, deal with it however you need, I don’t particularly mind, but it’s one of many self-serving, semi-deliberate misaprehensions people around here like to lean on to dismiss the current limitations of Fedi’s setup, and that habit does bum me out. Because, you know, being part of this community, despite your implications, I would like for it to be more popular than it is. Not fully mainstream, perhaps, because I do like the weird, cozy mid-90s forum feel of the thing, but… yeah, a bit.
And definitely I would have liked to see Masto put up more of a fight instead of being steamrolled by Elon. That was a legitimate bummer.
This comment should be deleted soon
Did I ever claim to be trying to do that? I mean, it’s starting to get convoluted, but my initial point was that people attribute effects to decentralization it doesn’t have by itself, so the differences between the more consolidated Bluesky ecosystem and the less consolidated Masto ecosystem in particular aren’t as meaningful as the graph in the OP suggests.
You were the one who popped up to claim that decentralization prevents monocultures. I just disagreed with that statement and pointed out that… yeah, that’s one of the magic effects people claim that don’t seem to really happen.
Whether that’s a problem or how big of one is entirely up for debate. All I’m saying is it’s not much of a real advantage, as far as I can tell. I’m both here and in BS, so I clearly don’t find either that effect or the lack of that effect to be a dealbreaker, if it exists at all. I’m claiming it doesn’t exist in the first place.
My educated guess is that what would meaningfully change how this conversation is playing out is me unequivocally siding with the home team and bashing the away team. The fact that I’m not necessarily bashing either (or at times I’m bashing both) is perceived as hostility or siding with the away team, because people have squishy brains and that’s how the Internet works and all social media was a mistake.
This comment should be deleted soon
Hah. That is a shockingly… optimistic? take in a world where even Twitter didn’t crash and burn. I would ask how resilient that level of delusion is to observable reality, but refer to my earlier comments about social media and squishy brains.
deleted by creator
I mean, it’s not, though. Things either happen or they don’t. You made a prediction that does not match reality.
This comment should be deleted soon