It’s a big leap from “is this the best we can achieve?” to “let’s abandon all societal structure and law”.
You think you can get rid of power structures. I’m telling you that it’s a pipe dream. We are fundamentally constrained. That’s not the same as saying society as it is is the best we can ever do.
Anarchism isn’t about abandoning “all societal structure” though. Authority and law are not necessary for organisation.
Anarchism in praxis is largely about working towards the social change required to properly challenge/undermine the power structures that control our lives.
Of course authority and law are necessary for organisation. Its beyond crazy to think otherwise. Can you think of a single organisation that doesn’t have rules and power structures?
When anarchists talk about authority and hierarchy, they’re talking about coercive/oppressive power structures. Organisation doesn’t have to be founded in obedience and control, it can also be built upon mutual agreement/consent and cooperation. Are you really unable to imagine any examples of the latter?
As for laws, they really aren’t all that good at preventing “crime”, because they don’t address the fundamental reasons why people turn to “crime” in the first place. Plus, there are plenty of legal things which are unethical and plenty of ethical things which are illegal.
Some (religious) people think that without fear of god humans are immoral. I think that if the only reason you’re not murdering people is out of fear of god then there’s something seriously wrong with you. Replace “god” with “the law” and the same reasoning applies.
It’s a big leap from “is this the best we can achieve?” to “let’s abandon all societal structure and law”.
You think you can get rid of power structures. I’m telling you that it’s a pipe dream. We are fundamentally constrained. That’s not the same as saying society as it is is the best we can ever do.
Anarchism isn’t about abandoning “all societal structure” though. Authority and law are not necessary for organisation.
Anarchism in praxis is largely about working towards the social change required to properly challenge/undermine the power structures that control our lives.
Of course authority and law are necessary for organisation. Its beyond crazy to think otherwise. Can you think of a single organisation that doesn’t have rules and power structures?
When anarchists talk about authority and hierarchy, they’re talking about coercive/oppressive power structures. Organisation doesn’t have to be founded in obedience and control, it can also be built upon mutual agreement/consent and cooperation. Are you really unable to imagine any examples of the latter?
As for laws, they really aren’t all that good at preventing “crime”, because they don’t address the fundamental reasons why people turn to “crime” in the first place. Plus, there are plenty of legal things which are unethical and plenty of ethical things which are illegal.
Some (religious) people think that without fear of god humans are immoral. I think that if the only reason you’re not murdering people is out of fear of god then there’s something seriously wrong with you. Replace “god” with “the law” and the same reasoning applies.