if someone said “redheads are hot” i’d say “alright”

if someone said “all redheads are hot” i’d say “that’s bullshit and you know it”

one is a generalization the other is an absolute statement

You said “all nerds are sexy” you’re contradicting yourself here. Maybe you meant “nerdiness is sexy” but that is not what you said.

You really need to think about the worst case when you use the word “all”

Think about the most acne-ridden, morbidly obese, ungroomed, mentally ill, racist incel with the worst hygiene. But hey, he plays starcraft and learned some computer programming. Down to smash?

Oh, come on now. You and I both know that’s bullshit