I don’t agree. The only thing about goblins is that they are bankers. If you hear bankers, and think Jews, that may be that You are stereotyping. Shacklebolt and Cho Chang I consider just poorly though through names. As for the elves being slaves, that has depth. It’s not just, elves want to be slaves so we keep them as slaves. The characters in the books ask them, if they like what they are doing. They like it, they talk about it, we see the point of view of elves. It may be my childhood innocence talking, but I never took it as malicious writing. Maybe unconscious stereotyping. But it was the 90s, she didn’t know better. But all in all now she is a shit human being and I despise her views.
If you hear bankers, and think Jews, that may be that You are stereotyping.
Or maybe the fact that you see figures modeled after a Nazi stereotype of Jewish people and think “just bankers” is a You ignoring the obvious to defend the indefensible thing.
Shacklebolt and Cho Chang I consider just poorly though through names
Nobody forced her to give them racist names. That she did so anyway is lazy stereotyping at best, intentional racist belittling at worst.
As for the elves being slaves, that has depth.
Here we go with the slavery apologia…
The characters in the books ask them, if they like what they are doing. They like it, they talk about it, we see the point of view of elves
Just because they’ve been institutionalized to think that slavery is the only way of life for them doesn’t make it ok.
She could easily NOT have had slaves in a world where everything they’re forced to do can be accomplished with magic. But no, she CHOSE for there to be slaves and then endorse slavery by making the slaves “want it”
It may be my childhood innocence talking, but I never took it as malicious writing
Definitely you missing it at first, yes. Which is understandable for a child. You should know better than to defend it now, though.
Maybe unconscious stereotyping. But it was the 90s, she didn’t know better
That’s bullshit. She had full control of an entire magical world and CHOSE to inject unchallenged and lampshaded bigotry into it.
Whether the 1990s or the fucking 1890s, it’s her job to know better and do better.
Thanks for the comments, Man. I appreciate the fact, that You want to talk about it. If You let me, I Will respond later, as now I’m after a night shift and drunk. Would You be willing to tell me Your age? I think that is an important thing in analysing HP and the authors views. I was born in 87,but I’m polish, so the books got to me a little bit later than most st of the world.
If You let me, I Will respond later, as now I’m after a night shift and drunk
Sure, enjoy your night lol
Would You be willing to tell me Your age? I think that is an important thing in analysing HP and the authors views. I was born in 87,but I’m polish, so the books got to me a little bit later than most st of the world.
I’m 41 but didn’t read them as they came out but rather well into my twenties.
Embarrassingly, I missed a lot of the more problematic stuff back then in spite of not being a child, but I thought harder about it later when learning from others spelling it out for me heh
I don’t agree. The only thing about goblins is that they are bankers. If you hear bankers, and think Jews, that may be that You are stereotyping. Shacklebolt and Cho Chang I consider just poorly though through names. As for the elves being slaves, that has depth. It’s not just, elves want to be slaves so we keep them as slaves. The characters in the books ask them, if they like what they are doing. They like it, they talk about it, we see the point of view of elves. It may be my childhood innocence talking, but I never took it as malicious writing. Maybe unconscious stereotyping. But it was the 90s, she didn’t know better. But all in all now she is a shit human being and I despise her views.
That’s categorically NOT true.
Or maybe the fact that you see figures modeled after a Nazi stereotype of Jewish people and think “just bankers” is a You ignoring the obvious to defend the indefensible thing.
Nobody forced her to give them racist names. That she did so anyway is lazy stereotyping at best, intentional racist belittling at worst.
Here we go with the slavery apologia…
Just because they’ve been institutionalized to think that slavery is the only way of life for them doesn’t make it ok.
She could easily NOT have had slaves in a world where everything they’re forced to do can be accomplished with magic. But no, she CHOSE for there to be slaves and then endorse slavery by making the slaves “want it”
Definitely you missing it at first, yes. Which is understandable for a child. You should know better than to defend it now, though.
That’s bullshit. She had full control of an entire magical world and CHOSE to inject unchallenged and lampshaded bigotry into it.
Whether the 1990s or the fucking 1890s, it’s her job to know better and do better.
Thanks for the comments, Man. I appreciate the fact, that You want to talk about it. If You let me, I Will respond later, as now I’m after a night shift and drunk. Would You be willing to tell me Your age? I think that is an important thing in analysing HP and the authors views. I was born in 87,but I’m polish, so the books got to me a little bit later than most st of the world.
Sure, enjoy your night lol
I’m 41 but didn’t read them as they came out but rather well into my twenties.
Embarrassingly, I missed a lot of the more problematic stuff back then in spite of not being a child, but I thought harder about it later when learning from others spelling it out for me heh