Except that this isn’t a straw man argument. Of course, nobody puts it quite so bluntly, but some people do in fact argue in this way. One can certainly debate what constitutes torture, but don’t pretend that there aren’t people who express violent fantasies about those they regard as deserving or undesirable to society.
Anyone who comments about rapists getting used as sex toys in prison, for one. Anyone who makes a drop-the-soap-joke. Anyone who supports texas not having climate controls in prison. To some extent, anyone who supports chain gangs or forced agricultural labor. The us constitution, and its writers, who said slavery was a suitable punishment for crime.
I suppose my original statement was poorly worded. I wasn’t referring to people who are fundamentally opposed to the death penalty, but rather to those who, in certain cases, believe that it is not sufficient as a punishment and take it as an excuse to advocate for things, I would consider torture. In fact, I would also expect people who are opposed to the death penalty to speak out against torture as well, even though the two issues are probably not mutually exclusive.
see that’s why i think of it as a straw man.in my experience, people advocating for the death penalty tend to think of criminal punishment primarily as… punishment, rather than the attempt att rehabilitation we’ve come to largely agree that it is.
most people, i think, recognise that a majority of criminal activity is born, directly or indirectly, from circumstance. therefore, most criminals act out of a perceived necessity. the criminal justice system exists to make sure that these people are rehabilitated (with varying effectiveness…), and that they are kept from society until they are. the punishment is the separation, the penance is rehabilitation.
the punishment view seems to me more like an “eye for an eye” mindset. they did an illegal thing, so they should suffer. i’ve seen the view that the death penalty is “too good” for certain criminals, but i’ve never seen someone be anti-death penalty, pro-torture. i guess if you count the people ambiguous to prison reform into the pro-torture camp you’ll bump the headcount somewhat.
you dropped your straw man outside
Except that this isn’t a straw man argument. Of course, nobody puts it quite so bluntly, but some people do in fact argue in this way. One can certainly debate what constitutes torture, but don’t pretend that there aren’t people who express violent fantasies about those they regard as deserving or undesirable to society.
Bro.
I’m not your bro, pal. :)
who?
Anyone who comments about rapists getting used as sex toys in prison, for one. Anyone who makes a drop-the-soap-joke. Anyone who supports texas not having climate controls in prison. To some extent, anyone who supports chain gangs or forced agricultural labor. The us constitution, and its writers, who said slavery was a suitable punishment for crime.
oh so it’s a us-only thing?
Now thatsa strawman!
Nope, definitely a sentiment elsewhere
among people opposed to the death penalty though?
I suppose my original statement was poorly worded. I wasn’t referring to people who are fundamentally opposed to the death penalty, but rather to those who, in certain cases, believe that it is not sufficient as a punishment and take it as an excuse to advocate for things, I would consider torture. In fact, I would also expect people who are opposed to the death penalty to speak out against torture as well, even though the two issues are probably not mutually exclusive.
see that’s why i think of it as a straw man.in my experience, people advocating for the death penalty tend to think of criminal punishment primarily as… punishment, rather than the attempt att rehabilitation we’ve come to largely agree that it is.
most people, i think, recognise that a majority of criminal activity is born, directly or indirectly, from circumstance. therefore, most criminals act out of a perceived necessity. the criminal justice system exists to make sure that these people are rehabilitated (with varying effectiveness…), and that they are kept from society until they are. the punishment is the separation, the penance is rehabilitation.
the punishment view seems to me more like an “eye for an eye” mindset. they did an illegal thing, so they should suffer. i’ve seen the view that the death penalty is “too good” for certain criminals, but i’ve never seen someone be anti-death penalty, pro-torture. i guess if you count the people ambiguous to prison reform into the pro-torture camp you’ll bump the headcount somewhat.
I remember seeing a lot of fuss about an exception needing to be made for Brevik
Looking this guy up, have you considered that maybe part of the argument is that this Brevik is kind of an inhuman monster.
Like this guy sounds terrible, we should what? Give him a TV and a little library and a bit of therapy? Maybe we can fix him?
isn’t that sort of the opposite? norway’s prisons are in no way torturous
my dad does